#1 This person who got conned:

PM_ME_YOUR_HARIBO / Via reddit.com

#2 This person who redefined having two left feet:

teddytalent / Via reddit.com

#3 This person who is still looking for the other half of their dress:

Theheadandthefart / Via reddit.com

#4 This person who bought some sick sunglasses…for an American Girl doll:

Keo_Manne / Via twitter.com

#5 This person who recevied a DIY gone bad:

harley_g00d / Via reddit.com

#6 This person who served up some toilet paper realness:

theillusionary / Via reddit.com

#7 This person who discovered that DHL exists in space:

Phiziicz / Via reddit.com

#8 This person who at least has good taste:

Sergiotor9 / Via reddit.com

#9 This who, honestly, received an equally badass hat:

Kritzelkrieger / Via reddit.com

#10 This person whose killer koalas turned out to be a little less frightening:

orcgore / Via reddit.com

#11 This person who at least had his next Halloween costume ready:

joshxdavid / Via twitter.com

#12 This person who got what appears to be a very comfortable blanket-sweater:

SophiaCK / Via twitter.com

#13 This person who found a sweater that showed off every single one of those abs:

Jasonfrost3425 / Via reddit.com

#14 This person who invented a new way to use leggings:

Roses88 / Via reddit.com

#15 This person who got a human-sized pillow case:

faarraahh_ / Via twitter.com

#16 This person who tried on their new and improved Yeezys:

AndyLeeman91 / Via twitter.com

And finally, this person who got the prom dress of her nightmares:

jjacoby14 / Via twitter.com

More info r/ExpectationVsReality, H/T BuzzFeed, Preview photo credit: SophiaCK / twitter.com