1. This ice cream cone that asked its hair dresser to trim only an inch off the top
jtcatino
2. This popsicle that is really happy you’re going to eat it
FallenHeroOfficial
3. This chili-cheese dog that took it a little too seriously on the “cheese” part
Bison57
4. This bread that understands no one wants a dried cranberry in their baked goods
BMWBeme
5. This chip that can not live up to its birth name, “Tostitos Scoops”
Nvidia_Dragon
6. This popsicle that was woken up too early from its nap
markesl
7. Why didn’t they just remove half the packaging as well?
64Hassbot
8. Well, this sandwich that is 99.9% bread
Raptorious07
9. My niece ordered a clown ice cream and got this monstrosity
kriztin100
10. This sponge cake that doesn’t deliver on its promise
bobase510
11. The Starbucks ultimate caramel Crapuccino
gurdonbob
12. It looks like they threw a piece of cheese at my fish sandwich on its way to my car.
d4j2b5
13. This candy that looks like Captain America just got out of an intense battle
lemoneyliz
14. When ‘pizza’ is on a bagel, you can eat ‘pizza’ anytime.
nopenopenope17
15. This risotto that is still healthier than most anything else I’m eating
Befall
16. This taiyaki that gives you more than you pay for
harle
17. This pizza that is great for anyone who really likes thin crust
CTINSOllah
18. This was the last straw, Arbys. I knew better but tried anyway… never again! (Bacon Beef and Cheddar Burger)
heartbraden
19. This cheesecake that tries to give you some variety in each bite
Ollieacappella
20. This sponge bob ice cream that gives kids nightmares.
RighteousMerlin
21. This chicken that says it’s actually cooked, but is it really?
AMA_TheGhost
More info: Reddit’s Expectation Vs. Reality, H/T BuzzFeed